| Charles Allen Charlton (1868 - 1938) |
|
| Ethel Jane Portlock (1880 - 1959) |
| Benjamin Marvin Carnathan | Elsie Ann Charlton |
| b. d. br. occ. rel. cen. prc. |
b. 5 April 1895, Purcell, McClain County, Oklahoma d. 4 August 1963, Lonegrove, Carter County, Oklahoma br. Lonegrove, Carter County, Oklahoma occ. rel. cen. prc. |
| Ethel May Carnathan Mildred Carnathan James Hollis Carnathan B. M. Carnathan David Allen Carnathan Carl "Snooks' Carnathan Marie Carnathan Ralph Ray Carnathan Amanda Louise Carnathan Benny Carnathan |